Aamir Khan/Shahrukh Khan

[billllal]

I just dont know how come these two actors are representatives of muslims as they themselves have married non-muslim girls. Can anyone correct me if iam wrong. ( if you dont make ur wife muslim in case of hindu then you yourself also out of religion.)

[FastBowler]

Who cares?

[hashbb]

I don't think Aamir is muslim, or is he?

[FastBowler]

I don't think Aamir is muslim, or is he?



Who cares?

[billllal]

I don't think Aamir is muslim, or is he?

lol and wat about shah rukh

[defender]

Can anyone correct me if iam wrong. ( if you dont make ur wife muslim in case of hindu then you yourself also out of religion.)

If one of the married partner is non-muslim then the muslim partner is comitting adultery.

[Gabbar Singh]

Who says they represent anyone but themselves? I mean have they ever proclaimed to be representative of Muslims?

[AZ]

^ exactly.

[defender]

Who says they represent anyone but themselves? I mean have they ever proclaimed to be representative of Muslims?

But media portrays them as representive of muslims, you will notice it, when a controversy happens in india the media always asks them for their opinions from muslim prespectives.

[billllal]

But media portrays them as representive of muslims, you will notice it, when a controversy happens in india the media always asks them for their opinions from muslim prespectives.

exactly even they try to show as well that they are muslims or their representatives.

[ITGuy]

I just dont know how come these two actors are representatives of muslims as they themselves have married non-muslim girls. Can anyone correct me if iam wrong. ( if you dont make ur wife muslim in case of hindu then you yourself also out of religion.)

Think about them as:

Aamir Khan = Anil Sharma
Shahrukh Khan = Sunil Sharma

Happy ?

[AZ]

But media portrays them as representive of muslims, you will notice it, when a controversy happens in india the media always asks them for their opinions from muslim prespectives.

that's 'cos they love the attention, and won't miss a moment to be in the spotlight.

[FastBowler]

Who are any of you to judge their religion? Let them live their lives. If the media goes to them because they are Muslims, and not to you, that doesn't mean you have to start questioning their religion.

[Gabbar Singh]

I just dont know how come these two actors are representatives of muslims as they themselves have married non-muslim girls. Can anyone correct me if iam wrong. ( if you dont make ur wife muslim in case of hindu then you yourself also out of religion.)

If one of the married partner is non-muslim then the muslim partner is comitting adultery.

So what is the punishment for adultery and does adultery automatically make someone a non muslim as the OP is suggesting?

[ganeshran]

Their lives, their wives.

Why should we care?

[kingusama92]

Since, when did they become representatives of Islam and Muslims?

Let them live their lives and make their own decisions. They will answer to Allah [SWT].

We should worry about ourselves and how we can become better muslims.

[in_cutter]

I just dont know how come these two actors are representatives of muslims as they themselves have married non-muslim girls. Can anyone correct me if iam wrong. ( if you dont make ur wife muslim in case of hindu then you yourself also out of religion.)

Who cares??

Do you pray 5 times a day? Worry about yourself, not others.

[zimran72]

I just dont know how come these two actors are representatives of muslims as they themselves have married non-muslim girls. Can anyone correct me if iam wrong. ( if you dont make ur wife muslim in case of hindu then you yourself also out of religion.)

I agree completely and know how you feel. Those two are the Umaraa-ul-Momineen of the Muslim Ummah and the message they are giving is wrong. What should be done?

Let's have secret meetings billlal where we can dislike them?

[zimran72]

But media portrays them as representive of muslims, you will notice it, when a controversy happens in india the media always asks them for their opinions from muslim prespectives.

Who else should they go to? Osama Bin Laden? Or Ahmedinejad? Or perhaps Nawaz Sharif or the king of Saudi Arabia?

[kingusama92]

But media portrays them as representive of muslims, you will notice it, when a controversy happens in india the media always asks them for their opinions from muslim prespectives.

This is the media's fault for asking them questions of these sorts.

The few times I have seen them answer such questions, they usually are politically correct and don't boost about their knowledge concerning Islam.

I would have an issue with these two if they went around proclaiming they know what Islam is really about and that they are experts. I have never heard anything of this sort from them.

[QazzarFan]

all I can say is :facepalm:

[billllal]

So much bashing for me, i think i was wrong un conveying the msg. I think every single person is representative of their religion, now being a super star their is some extra burden on you. Being muslims, what they have done for muslims or islam? Or we should just accept the fact that they are no more muslims.

[cricnut]

So much bashing for me, i think i was wrong un conveying the msg. I think every single person is representative of their religion, now being a super star their is some extra burden on you. Being muslims, what they have done for muslims or islam? Or we should just accept the fact that they are no more muslims.

Being Muslims , what have Mohammed Asif , Amir and Salman Butt done for muslims or Islam?

Who has done more damage to the reputation of Muslims and Islamic Values ? Ones who sold there country for a quick buck or those who just married Non-Muslim women?

[Gabbar Singh]

So much bashing for me, i think i was wrong un conveying the msg. I think every single person is representative of their religion, now being a super star their is some extra burden on you. Being muslims, what they have done for muslims or islam? Or we should just accept the fact that they are no more muslims.


What have you done for Muslims or Islam recently?

[Omar Malik]

Let me guess what the next thread would be...."Are Veena Malik and Meera Muslims?"

[Garuda]

@OP

Why are you worried if Amir and Shahrukh are still Muslims or not?

[Sameer K]

Hahha, I thought this was a thread about which one was a better actor or something.

Let god judge them. You be the best muslim you can be and let god judge others.

[Garuda]

pardon me for saying this, but this is the most annoying thing I find in a lot of muslims.

They are worried about other's action than following the religion themselves.

Am I wrong in my assessment?

[ganeshran]

Hahha, I thought this was a thread about which one was a better actor or something.

Let god judge them. You be the best muslim you can be and let god judge others.

+1 Very valid point IMO

[QazzarFan]

So much bashing for me, i think i was wrong un conveying the msg. I think every single person is representative of their religion, now being a super star their is some extra burden on you. Being muslims, what they have done for muslims or islam? Or we should just accept the fact that they are no more muslims.

why the hell are you concerned about what they're doing? what are YOU doing as a muslim other than being extra critical ?

they are living peaceful lives, doing charity and contributing for their country and society more than others.

[hashbb]

pardon me for saying this, but this is the most annoying thing I find in a lot of muslims.

They are worried about other's action than following the religion themselves.

Am I wrong in my assessment?

You are spot on but I think you mean most pakistanis not most muslims

[Garuda]

You are spot on but I think you mean most pakistanis not most muslims
actually, most pakistanis I know personally are really liberals and do not get into religion too much. Whatever they follow or not follow, they keep it to themselves.

Hence I was more surprised when I read a lot of such threads in this forum. :)

[Prince_Pathan]

his life

**** sake

[kingusama92]

pardon me for saying this, but this is the most annoying thing I find in a lot of muslims.

They are worried about other's action than following the religion themselves.

Am I wrong in my assessment?

Actually, you are spot on.

It's a real poor habit. I agree with hashbb, its a Pakistani thing more then Muslim.

[DHONI183]

Why are we so keen to decide on others whether they are Muslims or not:boom:? Have we looked at ourselves to see whether we perform all those (religious and social) duties that God has enjoined upon us? And to those who think they are doing whole justice to their responsbilities, are you still sure you will go to the Paradise? If not then continue getting spritually better than questioning others beliefs.

[in_cutter]

Why do ppl create threads and then disappear?? OP at least fight your case.

[cric_fan82]

Well i thought it would be comparison thread! and i would ignore most of the garbage said and take it as a comparison!

Aamir for me

[billllal]

why the hell are you concerned about what they're doing? what are YOU doing as a muslim other than being extra critical ?

they are living peaceful lives, doing charity and contributing for their country and society more than others.

if iam not wrong you are definately a fan of either Aamir or Shahrukh. Iam concerend because they are stars and they have a bigger impact on the society than me. If i do some thing no one will be bothered but they are role model for the society and ther deeds get more attention.

And what iam doing as a muslim is that iam atleast not marrying a non-muslim woman and i think that is act one of the biggest sin, infact you are out from the religion.

[AZ]

if an actor is heavily influencing society, then that society is critically damaged already.

[billllal]

if an actor is heavily influencing society, then that society is critically damaged already.

not heavily influenced but definately more influenced than a common person.

[srh]

billllal bhai I can see that you have given these fatwas in this thread:
If a muslim man marry a non-muslim woman than he is no longer a muslim.
If a muslim man marry a non-muslim hindu woman than he is no longer a muslim.

I have a simple question: on what authority are you giving these fatwas?

[s2k]

Actually, you are spot on.

It's a real poor habit. I agree with hashbb, its a Pakistani thing more then Muslim.

and why is it so?Is it because a few corrupt leaders and dictators to consolidate their power and divert the attention of masses given the Pakistanis a notion that hey are the saviour of muslims and Islam?

[khankhan]

Who gives a rat ass. Let them live thier lives. Billal I think you should worry about yourself.

[billllal]

billllal bhai I can see that you have given these fatwas in this thread:
If a muslim man marry a non-muslim woman than he is no longer a muslim.
If a muslim man marry a non-muslim hindu woman than he is no longer a muslim.

I have a simple question: on what authority are you giving these fatwas?

u shuld know these as a basic knowledge bro.. if a muslim marry a non muslim ( not ahle kitab) and you dont make her muslim then you are automatically out from islam.

[ascher]

I just dont know how come these two actors are representatives of muslims as they themselves have married non-muslim girls. Can anyone correct me if iam wrong. ( if you dont make ur wife muslim in case of hindu then you yourself also out of religion.)

you just made a complete fool of yourself by asking such a trivial question in a multi-religious/ multi-ethnic forum!

Btw, how old are you?

Let me tell you that most of the world is not as much obsessed with religion as some of us pakistanis see our elders being, in their drawing room talks!

and just because some body has a muslim name or was born in an apparently muslim family, it doesn't mean that they have to either come to a certain standard of "musalmaniat" set by you or stop being muslims by changing their names !!

I hate shahrukh and like Amir due to their respective work though the moment I would feel that I have started having multiple orgasms just because their race, religion, language are like mine..I would rather go to a mental doctor!

which world are you living in bro?..stop getting fake pleasure by looking for those fake stamps of "musalmaniat" on human beings that are so much more than their religion... you don't need to take those "dadi amma's" bedtime stories, with an extra dose of "jazba-e-imani" and "over-rated muslim ummah" in them, so seriously!..if you know what i am saying!!! :D

Religion is a personal matter of every individual in the civilized world and I am afraid unless a person is a well known atheist..you just cant say anything about his/her religious beliefs in black and white!

[QazzarFan]

u shuld know these as a basic knowledge bro.. if a muslim marry a non muslim ( not ahle kitab) and you dont make her muslim then you are automatically out from islam.

you make it sound like a club membership....is that what your perception of Islam has come down to these days? why can't two people be happy and be with each other while respecting each other's faith...

[srh]

u shuld know these as a basic knowledge bro.. if a muslim marry a non muslim ( not ahle kitab) and you dont make her muslim then you are automatically out from islam.
to be honest I have never heard/read that a muslim man is no longer a muslim if he marries a non-muslim who is not ahle kitab. Can you give a reference (a sunnah or a fatwa) which can backup your claim?

[DHONI183]

u shuld know these as a basic knowledge bro.. if a muslim marry a non muslim ( not ahle kitab) and you dont make her muslim then you are automatically out from islam.

On what basis are you saying this?

Your "automatic" logics are compelling me to ask you this.

[DHONI183]

If one of the married partner is non-muslim then the muslim partner is comitting adultery.

Please explain me this.......

[RX]

To be fair the opening poster, he probably wants to know if they consider themselves Muslim.

Now many people here will say its none of his business, and frankly it isn't but theres no harm in wanting to find out. For example, someone may be interested to see what nationality a certain person is, the same way someone may be interested about what religion one may be. At the end of the day, they both are trying to identify the person albeit in different terms.

And to the 'liberals' on this forum, stop being so narrow minded. :))

[Gabbar Singh]

<iframe title="YouTube video player" class="youtube-player" type="text/html" width="640" height="390" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/KrMqeIoXFUY" frameborder="0" allowFullScreen></iframe>

[ascher]

To be fair the opening poster, he probably wants to know if they consider themselves Muslim.

Now many people here will say its none of his business, and frankly it isn't but theres no harm in wanting to find out. For example, someone may be interested to see what nationality a certain person is, the same way someone may be interested about what religion one may be. At the end of the day, they both are trying to identify the person albeit in different terms.

And to the 'liberals' on this forum, stop being so narrow minded. :))

He knows very well that both of them are on record acknowledging their muslim identities, his problem is that he is trying to watch their each and every activity by wearing those religious glasses, a kind of activity very common among us but almost ailien to the civilized world.

To put it in another way, he is one of those extremists who won't accept any one's nationality unless they wore their national flag up their sleeves 24/7...if you know what iam saying [;)]

[FastBowler]

Stop concerning yourself with who some actor married.