PTI disciplinary committee hands Imran Shah 0.5m fine for assaulting Karachi citizen [Update #129]

[shah_1]

Pti mpa from Karachi has misbehaved in the public

Strict action needs to be taken against this person.

[Abdullah719]

Pti mpa from Karachi has misbehaved in the public

Strict action needs to be taken against this person.

PTI MPA from PS-129 @dr_imranshah assaults a citizen near Stadium Road over crossing his SUV. Guards of the MPA kept abusing the citizen.#NayaPakistan pic.twitter.com/9Y7TcaBFR0

— Arbab Gul Muhammad (@ArbabGM) August 14, 2018

Throw him out.

[Mian]

PTI MPA from PS-129 @dr_imranshah assaults a citizen near Stadium Road over crossing his SUV. Guards of the MPA kept abusing the citizen.#NayaPakistan pic.twitter.com/9Y7TcaBFR0

— Arbab Gul Muhammad (@ArbabGM) August 14, 2018

Throw him out.

Need to be shown the door and made an example it's really sad to see son of great Dr Mohammah Ali Shah acting like a crook.

[Bewal Express]

Need to be shown the door and made an example it's really sad to see son of great Dr Mohammah Ali Shah acting like a crook.

The PTI needs to deal with these ******* like the complete cretins they are.

[Mian]

This is highly unacceptable behaviour in any case. No one is above the law. I apologise on behalf of my party MPA and rest assured justice will be done and will make sure it’s not repeated again. https://t.co/NpwMOdOWho

— Faisal Vawda (@FaisalVawdaPTI) August 14, 2018

[Mian]

You are not law or police!

Being a responsible citizen and a member of provincial assembly I have more responsibility towards my people, The viraled clip is half truth and misleading. I cannot turn a blind eye on someone doing injustice to a citizen for any reason. pic.twitter.com/t4a3BCeAta

— Dr. Imran Ali Shah (@dr_imranshah) August 14, 2018

[Mian]

Notice sent by party. wow that was quick

On the instructions of PTI President Karachi @Fsnaqvi

Show cause notice issued to Dr. Imran Ali Shah. pic.twitter.com/Bveplv6YDi

— • S I D R A • (@imran_sidra) August 14, 2018

[Syed1]

Notice sent by party. wow that was quick

On the instructions of PTI President Karachi @Fsnaqvi

Show cause notice issued to Dr. Imran Ali Shah. pic.twitter.com/Bveplv6YDi

— • S I D R A • (@imran_sidra) August 14, 2018

Well done.. if he is at fault he should be made an example of.

[Mian]

No one is above the law is the basic premise of Imran Khan’s Naya Pakiatan. An elected MPA taking the law into his own hands,for whatever reason,is completely unacceptable.We condemn this behaviour and expect strict action to be taken.
Show cause notice has been issued to the MPA pic.twitter.com/isGlFKovcV

— PTI (@PTIofficial) August 14, 2018

[mmkextreme_1]

Notice sent by party. wow that was quick

On the instructions of PTI President Karachi @Fsnaqvi

Show cause notice issued to Dr. Imran Ali Shah. pic.twitter.com/Bveplv6YDi

— • S I D R A • (@imran_sidra) August 14, 2018

Wow, that was swift by PTI, need to set an example.

Even though, he has tried to explain his side of the story in the video above. No one should take the law into there own hands. As an elected official he has additional responsibilities and should be setting an example for others.

Also, this is an official document, why is it spelled with "ur" and not "your" (bugs the crap out of me).

[Maverick84]

Wow, that was swift by PTI, need to set an example.

Even though, he has tried to explain his side of the story in the video above. No one should take the law into there own hands. As an elected official he has additional responsibilities and should be setting an example for others.

Also, this is an official document, why is it spelled with "ur" and not "your" (bugs the crap out of me).

She apologized on twitter for that mistake. She said it got auto corrected and in hurry she missed it.

[Mian]

Wow, that was swift by PTI, need to set an example.

Even though, he has tried to explain his side of the story in the video above. No one should take the law into there own hands. As an elected official he has additional responsibilities and should be setting an example for others.

Also, this is an official document, why is it spelled with "ur" and not "your" (bugs the crap out of me).

They fixed the letter and tweeted it again.

Revised version (without typos) of the show cause notice. pic.twitter.com/5LspiRLioP

— PTI (@PTIofficial) August 14, 2018

I have seen the video and am probing the matter, and simultaneously we are issuing a show cause notice to Dr. Imran Ali Shah.
Once all the facts are known we will let everyone know of the future course of action.

— Firdous Naqvi (@Fsnaqvi) August 14, 2018

[DrSchultz]

Good to see prompt action.

[mmkextreme_1]

She apologized on twitter for that mistake. She said it got auto corrected and in hurry she missed it.

They fixed the letter and tweeted it again.

Revised version (without typos) of the show cause notice. pic.twitter.com/5LspiRLioP

— PTI (@PTIofficial) August 14, 2018

I have seen the video and am probing the matter, and simultaneously we are issuing a show cause notice to Dr. Imran Ali Shah.
Once all the facts are known we will let everyone know of the future course of action.

— Firdous Naqvi (@Fsnaqvi) August 14, 2018

Much better

Thanks guys for the update.

[Mian]

Why is Bakhtawer and PPP asking for prompt action from PTI? For their information we the PTI walas are enough to play the opposition role within the party in these cases so they better focus on their own issues and take action against Nabil Gabol beating a guy on airport few days ago.

[shah_1]

Why is Bakhtawer and PPP asking for prompt action from PTI? For their information we the PTI walas are enough to play the opposition role within the party in these cases so they better focus on their own issues and take action against Nabil Gabol beating a guy on airport few days ago.

Ppp is known to be corrupt and incompetent

Pti took a very high moral ground by doing strong opposition last time and promised naya Pakistan. Every small thing will be scrutinized and unearthed. Now Imran Ismail old video is circulating of 4 million fruad and some woman doctor on reserved seat has a murky past

[Mian]

I never wanted to take law in my hand however it was in a spur of a moment that i momentarily lost my cool and reacted in a way that brought embarrassment to my position, my party and my supporters. 1/2 pic.twitter.com/nbnsmqGC11

— Dr. Imran Ali Shah (@dr_imranshah) August 14, 2018

Thereby, I sincerely and unconditionally apologise to Mr. Dawood and my voters and suppprters for my behaviour. I hope that you all will accept my apology and I promise to observe my conduct that is expected of me both morally and officially by the party's code of conduct. 2/2 pic.twitter.com/zeEnoMgOo0

— Dr. Imran Ali Shah (@dr_imranshah) August 14, 2018

[Savak]

Never thought I would see the day any MNA or MPA is forced to apologize with immediate effect for abusing his power and authority. This indeed is a Naya Pakistan.

[Mian]

Never thought I would see the day any MNA or MPA is forced to apologize with immediate effect for abusing his power and authority. This indeed is a Naya Pakistan.

[Strike!]

I think in the age of PTI, social media is about to gain a lot more importance, PTI supporters voice will be given a lot more significance in daily affairs.

[Syed1]

Compare this with NS motorcade killing child and not a single word of remorse by the bloody Nooras.

[Waseem]

So i woke up after 7 hours sleep and missed so much action lol.

A storm had been created by none other than PTI supporters themsleves.

Show cause notice issued.

Apology and explanation followed.

Culprit personally met the victim (who could be offender himself) and issue has been resolved.

In between all that, we saw some desperate attention seeking journalists and PPP leadership crying out loud 'Yeh ha tabdeeli"..."Ye hai Naya Pakistan".

I wish someone can tell them that it is Naya Pakistan where sitting MPA gets show cause notice within few hours and own party supporters become most fierce opponents. Of course people will make mistakes but trend continues if they go unpunished.

[giri26]

Hours after a video of Pakistan Tehreek-i-Insaf (PTI) lawmaker Dr Imran Ali Shah physically attacking a man in Karachi went viral on social media, the party on Tuesday issued a show-cause notice to the MPA, saying his actions were “unacceptable”.

The notice says that Shah should present his version "within 24 hours" otherwise he would be referred to the disciplinary committee for appropriate action.

The provincial lawmaker from Karachi's PS-129 constituency was caught on video slapping a man multiple times during a heated argument in the middle of a road in Karachi. The video that went viral showed that Dr Shah was accompanied by his armed guards, who also threatened the man.

After the video drew ire on social media, the PTI lawmaker released a video clarifying his stance regarding the incident. Dr Shah claimed that he was driving by when he saw a man "repeatedly hitting a poor man's car and stopped him".

Dr Shah said that he asked the man to "apologise to the poor man", adding that once people started dispersing "the man abused me and then pushed me".

The PTI lawmaker further claimed that he had only "pushed" the man; however, in the video it is visible that Dr Shah slapped the citizen multiple times.

Dr Shah's armed personal guards surrounded the man who was slapped and stopped him from following Dr Shah, who walked to his car and drove away.

In his clarification video, the PTI leader apologised for "hurting anyone's feelings", but remained adamant that he "could not stand back and watch 'injustice' take place like this".

Dr Shah further clarified that his car was not involved in any accident.

While talking to GeoTV later in the evening, Dr Shah repeated the contents of his video message, but could not properly answer host Shahzeb Khanzada's questions regarding the "unseen poor man" that the PTI leader claimed he was defending.

"The video is incomplete," Dr Shah claimed, adding that he had even "apologised to the man he had slapped".

To this, Khanzada pointed out that the available video evidence didn't support the lawmaker's claim, as he could be seen walking back to his car and driving away "right after slapping the man".

Shortly after the video went viral, PTI's Karachi wing president Dr Firdous Naqvi tweeted that he had seen the recording and was looking into the matter.

Dr Naqvi also said that Dr Shah has been issued a show-cause notice and he will "let everyone know of the future course of action".

Imran Ismail, the PTI's nominee for the post of Sindh governor, while talking to GeoTV said that party chief Imran Khan was "very upset" and "neither he [PTI chief] nor the party condones such behaviour".

https://www.dawn.com/news/1426979/pt...arachi-citizen

[waleed88]

Its no surprise to see this behavior from the MPA considering his leader slaps his party members in broad daylight before jalsas and has been caught doing that multiple times on camera..

[waleed88]

The guy said he has option but to forgive the guy he can't hold grudges agains the ruling party... welcome to Naya Pakistan.. this guy will be forgiven after the show cause and will carry on bullying people as an MPA with impudity

[waleed88]

This is not the first person Imran Ali Shah has harrassed, his step mother is also one of his victims...

[Abdullah719]

The guy said he has option but to forgive the guy he can't hold grudges agains the ruling party... welcome to Naya Pakistan.. this guy will be forgiven after the show cause and will carry on bullying people as an MPA with impudity

PTI suspends membership of MPA Imran Ali Shah

Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) on Thursday suspended party lawmaker Dr Imran Ali Shah for a month for beating up a man in PTI leader Ali Zaidi said Shah has been suspended till the disciplinary committee conducts an inquiry against him.

Ali Zaidi said, "the disciplinary committee has been asked to conclude the inquiry within a month."

Further, PTI member Najeeb Haroon tweeted, "Due to the seriousness of the matter, a suspension by the organisation is warranted for a period of one month with immediate effect."

He added, "Final action will be based on the recommendations of the disciplinary committee."

Meanwhile, PTI spokesperson Fawad Chaudhry said, "Matter is referred to PTI Sindh Chapter. They'll inquire into the issue and if needed appropriate action will be taken."

Earlier on Tuesday, after a video went viral of the MPA thrashing a citizen, PTI had issued a show-cause notice to him saying his actions were 'unacceptable'.

The notice said that Shah should present his version "within 24 hours" otherwise he would be referred to the disciplinary committee.

Shah, who was elected MPA from Karachi's PS-129 constituency during the July 25 polls, was caught on video slapping a man multiple times in the middle of a road in Karachi.

The video also showed the MPA's guards threatening the man.

After backlash on social media, the PTI lawmaker had released a video claiming that he was driving by when he saw a man "repeatedly hitting a poor man's car and stopped him".

The PTI lawmaker further claimed that he had only 'pushed' the man and apologised for "hurting anyone's feelings".

https://nation.com.pk/16-Aug-2018/pt...imran-ali-shah

[Angrez Pakistani]

Have deleted my tweet welcoming the decision to suspend Imran Shah because he hasn’t been suspended.

Hope Insafians fighting for him to get the boot will not stop - because legal action against him is even more of an improbability than him getting sanctioned by the party.

— Mosharraf Zaidi (@mosharrafzaidi) August 16, 2018

[Angrez Pakistani]

Have to do the same, sadly https://t.co/nYnkPcTmDt

— Zarrar Khuhro (@ZarrarKhuhro) August 16, 2018

[Abdullah719]

Clarification on road rage issue pertaining to Imran AlI Shah PTI MPA : matter is reffered to PTI Sindh Chapter they ll inquire into the issue and if needed appropriate action will be taken.

— Fawad Hussain (@fawadchaudhry) August 16, 2018

Why did Najeeb Haroon say he was suspended?

[hafeezrocks]

Massive respect for PTI.

[Bewal Express]

Its no surprise to see this behavior from the MPA considering his leader slaps his party members in broad daylight before jalsas and has been caught doing that multiple times on camera..

Maybe you should stick to losers that kill people in broad daylight. The election humiliation must still be really hurting

[Angrez Pakistani]

Maybe you should stick to losers that kill people in broad daylight. The election humiliation must still be really hurting

Maybe we should stick to the issue that is being discussed here?

[Abdullah719]

Maybe we should stick to the issue that is being discussed here?

Well, it is difficult to take PPP and PML-N fans seriously on this topic considering their track record.

[Angrez Pakistani]

Well, it is difficult to take PPP and PML-N fans seriously on this topic considering their track record.

But we are not discussing them here, are we?

[SarfiBabarHaris]

After Jibran Nasir, PTI is my fav party (mainly due to Imran and Asad Umar) along with AWP but seems like they have few badmash among their ranks.
Aik dosra drama hai Amir Liaqat sooner or later he will do a scene. Pti ko behtar banday nai milay?

[Bewal Express]

Maybe we should stick to the issue that is being discussed here?

He has a pop at IK at every opportunity but cant bring himself to say a single word about the murder at Model town.

[Bewal Express]

But we are not discussing them here, are we?

Nooras and PPP commenting on issue of human dignity is like Pol Pot commenting on the sanctity of life.

[Abdullah719]

But we are not discussing them here, are we?

No, but hypocrisy has to be exposed.

Back to the topic, I thought the matter had died down but a few more videos have surfaced over the past day or so due to which PTI supporters have once again raised their voice on social media. Hopefully the matter is dealt with appropriately, an apology is not close to being enough.

[Angrez Pakistani]

He has a pop at IK at every opportunity but cant bring himself to say a single word about the murder at Model town.

Two wrongs don’t make one right.

[Bewal Express]

But we are not discussing them here, are we?

So are you saying we cant comment on these peoples hypocrisy? Where were these people when 14 people were murdered in broad daylight.

[Bewal Express]

No, but hypocrisy has be to be exposed.

Back to the topic, I thought the matter had died down but a few more videos have surfaced over the past day or so due to which PTI supporters have once again raised their voice on social media. Hopefully the matter is dealt with appropriately, an apology is not close to being enough.

I agree, this guy needs to be made an example of.

[Angrez Pakistani]

No, but hypocrisy has be to be exposed.

Back to the topic, I thought the matter had died down but a few more videos have surfaced over the past day or so due to which PTI supporters have once again raised their voice on social media. Hopefully the matter is dealt with appropriately, an apology is not close to being enough.

People should raise their voice against such behaviour. And let’s be honest, PTI should have been thrown out of the party instead of being temporarily suspended and being referred to the Sindh chapter. He assaulted a citizen in broad daylight. What’s their to investigate?

[SarfiBabarHaris]

This ghunda gardi reminds me of Anjum Aqeel the ex MNA of PMLN from Islamabad urban where him and his cheelay beat a senior teacher because the teacher didn't give admission to the son of one of his workers somewhere around 2009. Since then PMLN is my least fav party as its composed of ghundas like Anjum Aqeel and the fact that Nawaz approved such a ghunda in an area like Islamabad where you can find thousands of clean candidates. That incident is till date in my memory.

[Angrez Pakistani]

Imran Ali Shah*

[IMMY69]

People should raise their voice against such behaviour. And let’s be honest, PTI should have been thrown out of the party instead of being temporarily suspended and being referred to the Sindh chapter. He assaulted a citizen in broad daylight. What’s their to investigate?

So please set up threads for each misdemeanor done by PMLN and PPP members. Otherwise you're just a hypocrite like all the other supporters of crooks.

Actually scrap that, PP will most likely crash with the vast number of threads being created. Maybe one thread for all the crimes will do.

Until you can do that I think it's best you keep your hypocrisy to yourself.

[Angrez Pakistani]

So please set up threads for each misdemeanor done by PMLN and PPP members. Otherwise you're just a hypocrite like all the other supporters of crooks.

Actually scrap that, PP will most likely crash with the vast number of threads being created. Maybe one thread for all the crimes will do.

Until you can do that I think it's best you keep your hypocrisy to yourself.

Whattt??? You think I am a PPP supporter? I don’t understand this mindset. Everyone here wants to expose everyone else’s hypocrisy but end up coming across as hypocrites themselves. Your defence of PTI’s inability to take definitive actions against their rogue members is that everyone else is a hypocrite because their favourites are bad, very bad, parties. It’s ridiculous!

[Angrez Pakistani]

So please set up threads for each misdemeanor done by PMLN and PPP members. Otherwise you're just a hypocrite like all the other supporters of crooks.

Actually scrap that, PP will most likely crash with the vast number of threads being created. Maybe one thread for all the crimes will do.

Until you can do that I think it's best you keep your hypocrisy to yourself.

Why create a separate thread if you can bash them here?

[IMMY69]

Why create a separate thread if you can bash them here?

Because when we had five years of threads pointing out the glaring deficiencies of the both the PMLN and PPP, all the supporters would go missing. Now we have one PTI member who did wrong and the PTI has taken immediate action suddenly we have you questioning everything.

It's a bit rich coming from supporters of crooks.

[IMMY69]

The funny thing is that I have taken two uber cars in recent times.
One was a week before the elections. I asked the Pakistany driver who he was supporting and he said PMLN.
Then went on to say what a Lion Nawaz is and give me the history of pakistany politics and how the Military controls everything.

Then just a few days ago the second Uber driver (also a Pakistany) what he thinks of IK and where the future lies for the country. For 30 minutes I was lectured on how he's an establishment man and that he is only in power because of the military and if it was not because of the army then PLMN would have easily won the election. Then he also started talking about the history of Pakistan and how the military has always dictated who is in power. He went to say that IK is corrupt and that he will destroy the country.

Both times I couldn't get a word in until the very end of my journey when I asked them why is there one rule for Sharif and another for IK?

The hypocrisy is blinding. The extent people go to back crooks and are not even prepared to give someone else a go, someone who has dedicated the last 22 years to Pakistan, not to mention the charity work he's done.

[SarfiBabarHaris]

Aik dosra drama hai Amir Liaqat sooner or later he will do a scene. Pti ko behtar banday nai milay?

First incite hatred against a community which leads to killing of many and then apologize, thats Amir Liaqat for you. he again incited violence against Ahmadis in 2014 which resulted in killing of 1 Ahmadi. Drama!

I was discussing with my bro, who is a bgi supporter of pti, why he is given ticket by pti but we couldn't come to a possible reason. Really hope this hate preacher is kicked out from pti even if it cost them a seat. humanitarian principles should be above everything. I get it that for people it doesnt matter much what is happening to minorities as they have so many problems of their own but personally i believe 1 human life is more important than my broken street, water shortage in my home etc.

[Bewal Express]

People should raise their voice against such behaviour. And let’s be honest, PTI should have been thrown out of the party instead of being temporarily suspended and being referred to the Sindh chapter. He assaulted a citizen in broad daylight. What’s their to investigate?

Let me play devils advocate- dont you think he deserves to be heard.

[Bewal Express]

The funny thing is that I have taken two uber cars in recent times.
One was a week before the elections. I asked the Pakistany driver who he was supporting and he said PMLN.
Then went on to say what a Lion Nawaz is and give me the history of pakistany politics and how the Military controls everything.

Then just a few days ago the second Uber driver (also a Pakistany) what he thinks of IK and where the future lies for the country. For 30 minutes I was lectured on how he's an establishment man and that he is only in power because of the military and if it was not because of the army then PLMN would have easily won the election. Then he also started talking about the history of Pakistan and how the military has always dictated who is in power. He went to say that IK is corrupt and that he will destroy the country.

Both times I couldn't get a word in until the very end of my journey when I asked them why is there one rule for Sharif and another for IK?

The hypocrisy is blinding. The extent people go to back crooks and are not even prepared to give someone else a go, someone who has dedicated the last 22 years to Pakistan, not to mention the charity work he's done.

Noora illiterates never allow you to speak, too scared to debate so they start shouting.

[Angrez Pakistani]

Because when we had five years of threads pointing out the glaring deficiencies of the both the PMLN and PPP, all the supporters would go missing. Now we have one PTI member who did wrong and the PTI has taken immediate action suddenly we have you questioning everything.

It's a bit rich coming from supporters of crooks.

Take it as a compliment. Other parties are not even worth discussing.

[Angrez Pakistani]

Let me play devils advocate- dont you think he deserves to be heard.

Duh. He should have resigned from the party first. He could’ve applied for the party membership after clearing his name from the charges against him. Isn’t that what IK asked from NS? Why have two different sets of rules?

[Syed1]

I for one am perfectly satisfied by PTI's handling of this issue. You know what, had they ignored it the jahil supporters of Noon and PPP would be shouting at the top of their lungs conveniently forgetting that their parties have been doing much worse without much accountability for the last four decades.

[Mian]

Imran Shah should be shown the door based on that video alone where he is beating the person but his step mother isn't an angel and the doctors of Karachi know her background so her video shouldn't be taken seriously she is just using as an opportunity.

Any idea when PPP is going to take action against Nabeel Gabol for beating person on an airport?

[Loralai]

He should have resigned immediately. The fact that he has been referred to Sindh Chapter is insufficient - he attacked a citizen.

Lets hope IK kick him out of the party if he doesn't have the good sense to resign.

[Mian]

MD, MRCS (Ed), MRCS (Glasgow) Dip. SICOT (Sweden), FRCS (Trauma and Orthropaedics) Royal College of Surgeons of England Orthopaedic & Trauma Surgeon

Another reason to believe degrees can't make you a better person And he is Trauma Surgeon

[IMMY69]

Duh. He should have resigned from the party first. He could’ve applied for the party membership after clearing his name from the charges against him. Isn’t that what IK asked from NS? Why have two different sets of rules?

Are you being serious or just trolling here?

We're discussing a party member here not the prime minister of pakistan who was facing corruption charges at the time. Slight difference.

Yes this Doctor saab should have resigned. But Imran Khan or the Party cannot just sack him without due process.

[IMMY69]

He should have resigned immediately. The fact that he has been referred to Sindh Chapter is insufficient - he attacked a citizen.

Lets hope IK kick him out of the party if he doesn't have the good sense to resign.

This is the crux. Lets wait and see the outcome

[Angrez Pakistani]

Are you being serious or just trolling here?

We're discussing a party member here not the prime minister of pakistan who was facing corruption charges at the time. Slight difference.

Yes this Doctor saab should have resigned. But Imran Khan or the Party cannot just sack him without due process.

Bro, you can call me a troll or an idealist but all of it is just semantics. I believe that in a true democracy, every party member is potentially a future PM candidate. So if we don’t start the process of accountability from both top and the bottom then we will all be stuck in an endless loop of whataboutism.

[Angrez Pakistani]

Imran Shah should be shown the door based on that video alone where he is beating the person but his step mother isn't an angel and the doctors of Karachi know her background so her video shouldn't be taken seriously she is just using as an opportunity.

Any idea when PPP is going to take action against Nabeel Gabol for beating person on an airport?

Exactly. Don’t understand why it’s taking them so long. But, on a side note, let him use all of his options and in all honesty there is no point in holding PTI to a higher moral standard than any other political party.

[Major]

him getting suspended from the party means nothing.

Real change is when legal action could be taken.

If there isn't any legal action, then this is just dramaybaazi.

[Syed1]

him getting suspended from the party means nothing.

Real change is when legal action could be taken.

If there isn't any legal action, then this is just dramaybaazi.

What did PPP do about Nabil Gabol beating up a civilian at Karachi airport. Those living in glass houses shouldn't be throwing stones. Know your place

[Angrez Pakistani]

What did PPP do about Nabil Gabol beating up a civilian at Karachi airport. Those living in glass houses shouldn't be throwing stones. Know your place

PTI should not compare themselves to PPP. Wasn’t that the whole point of “tabdeeli”?

[Syed1]

PTI should not compare themselves to PPP. Wasn’t that the whole point of “tabdeeli”?

The person I quoted is a voter of PPP so obviously I will bring in PPP, and for the record you are no one to tell who I can bring and not bring in an argument. You seemed to have donned the sheriff's role on this thread trying to tell people what they should say.

[Loralai]

What did PPP do about Nabil Gabol beating up a civilian at Karachi airport. Those living in glass houses shouldn't be throwing stones. Know your place

Two wrongs don't make a right bhaijan.

PTI needs to take serious action against this guy immediately to prevent their reputation from being further damaged.

[Syed1]

Two wrongs don't make a right bhaijan.

PTI needs to take serious action against this guy immediately to prevent their reputation from being further damaged.

Nabil Gabol pushed and shoved a passenger - no action

Nawaz Sharif motorcade killed child - no action

Imran Ali Shah slapped civilian - PTI issues show cause notice within a couple of hours, offender MPA having to go to victims house to apologize, PTI still deciding whether to suspend membership - Jahil liberal brigade: "PTI should do more"



Liberals and mullahs are eating away at this country like termite.

[Angrez Pakistani]

The person I quoted is a voter of PPP so obviously I will bring in PPP, and for the record you are no one to tell who I can bring and not bring in an argument. You seemed to have donned the sheriff's role on this thread trying to tell people what they should say.

I’m not silencing anyone. I’m just saying that comparing PTI with PPP is not the brightest idea for any of the many IK fan boys.

[Bewal Express]

Duh. He should have resigned from the party first. He could’ve applied for the party membership after clearing his name from the charges against him. Isn’t that what IK asked from NS? Why have two different sets of rules?

So you are comparing a guy that has stolen billions with a guy that may have committed an assault.This guy is not the PM, he cannot influence the Criminal justice system like NS. He should be suspended from the party and an investigation should be held.

[Bewal Express]

him getting suspended from the party means nothing.

Real change is when legal action could be taken.

If there isn't any legal action, then this is just dramaybaazi.

Maybe you should stick to commenting on AZ And Nabil. After all that is what you voted for, we dont need lectures from people that have voted for people that have stolen billions.

[Bewal Express]

I’m not silencing anyone. I’m just saying that comparing PTI with PPP is not the brightest idea for any of the many IK fan boys.

The PTI have already shown that they are aware of public opinion, something that has not happened in recent PK history.

[Angrez Pakistani]

So you are comparing a guy that has stolen billions with a guy that may have committed an assault.This guy is not the PM, he cannot influence the Criminal justice system like NS. He should be suspended from the party and an investigation should be held.

You can’t compare, for example, rapists with money launderers but in the eye of the law they are both criminals. I agree that the guy is not the PM but he’s the member of the ruling party which CAN influence the CJS.

[Angrez Pakistani]

The PTI have already shown that they are aware of public opinion, something that has not happened in recent PK history.

I think every party is aware of public opinion. You might wanna google Imdad Pitafi fiasco to realise it.

[Bewal Express]

I think every party is aware of public opinion. You might wanna google Imdad Pitafi fiasco to realise it.

Yes off course they are, thats why the dynasties of the 2 parties carry on with gay abandon, or SS is the PM is the candidate for PM for the Nooras after 14 were murdered in broad daylight. Which world do you live in?

[Bewal Express]

You can’t compare, for example, rapists with money launderers but in the eye of the law they are both criminals. I agree that the guy is not the PM but he’s the member of the ruling party which CAN influence the CJS.

In the eyes of the law littering is also illegal, so you think that a person throwing litter should be treated as the PM. Your arguments are beyond ludicrous .

[Angrez Pakistani]

In the eyes of the law littering is also illegal, so you think that a person throwing litter should be treated as the PM. Your arguments are beyond ludicrous .

A PM can be disqualified for assaulting a common citizen. I’m sure he can also be disqualified for littering since that is also a crime but littering is not what we are debating here.

[Angrez Pakistani]

In the eyes of the law littering is also illegal, so you think that a person throwing litter should be treated as the PM. Your arguments are beyond ludicrous .

The tragedy is that we are a nation of quick fixes. We want our PM to be spotless but we don’t see polical workers who commit crimes as necessarily law breakers. I agree that everyone can not be treated as PM but you can’t have one rule for a common man and another for a PM.

[Angrez Pakistani]

I just want to ask a few question, if a British politician was caught on camera assaulting a commoner wouldn’t he be behind bars by now, regardless of his political leanings? Wouldn’t you be happy to see Imran Ali Shah being kicked out of his political party and behind bars, if he were to belong to PPP or PML-N? People justifying PTI’s inaction and telling us how they have gained a moral victory over other parties with regards to this issue are nothing but hypocrites of the highest order.