Oh Dear that was Awful

[Saj]

We've all seen those horror dismissals where a batsman plays a horrendous stroke at a crucial juncture of the game and gets himself out.

Today Michael Clarke jumped down the wicket so far, that his dismissal could almsot have been declared a runout, rather than a stumping. It gave Dhoni so much time that he could have done a few steps of the bhangra and then taken the bails off.

What was Clarke thinking at a time when he was their last realistic hope?

[jackal786]

Originally Posted by Saj We've all seen those horror dismissals where a batsman plays a horrendous stroke at a crucial juncture of the game and gets himself out. Today Michael Clarke jumped down the wicket so far, that his dismissal could almsot have been declared a runout, rather than a stumping. It gave Dhoni so much time that he could have done a few steps of the bhangra and then taken the bails off. What was Clarke thinking at a time when he was their last realistic hope?

One of those brain explosions.. in pressure situations it happens. Remember Dravid played totally uncharacteristic shot on day 1.

[Easa]

But it was a splendid innings. If only he didn't charge down the track, Australia could have pulled off a highly unlikely win.

Good to watch though, so no complaints from me.

[Perth93]

clarke proved he'sanouther faltu pretender, a more professional version of yuvraj singh.

players like him always let their teams down.

but i am not complaing either.

[Usman Chadda]

He had to go for quick runs as he had only three tail-enders after him. Its not easy to hit Kumble for quick runs playing from the crease and the best way to disrupt the spinner's line-and-length is to go down the track. Just one of those things that look magnificent when they come off and look pretty ugly when they dont

[Daoud]

Cant really fault Clarke. The match was realistically over before he got out and the tailend slogging was akin to Astle's double century against England. Great entertainment and kept a hope alive when there wasnt any but once the thought of an Aussie comeback started spreading there really wasnt any way it would happen cause the pressure was back on them. Its all good slogging when the pressure is off, but it rarely comes off when it comes back to them

[jackal786]

Originally Posted by Daoud Cant really fault Clarke. The match was realistically over before he got out and the tailend slogging was akin to Astle's double century against England. Great entertainment and kept a hope alive when there wasnt any but once the thought of an Aussie comeback started spreading there really wasnt any way it would happen cause the pressure was back on them. Its all good slogging when the pressure is off, but it rarely comes off when it comes back to them

It was almost like Murali, Malinga slogging in the company of Sangakkara. They also threatened to pull off a miracle.

[Usman Chadda]

Originally Posted by jackal786 It was almost like Murali, Malinga slogging in the company of Sangakkara. They also threatened to pull off a miracle.

That was looking possible though, the way Sangakkara was playing

[jackal786]

Originally Posted by Usman Sahib That was looking possible though, the way Sangakkara was playing

Rudy Koertzen had other ideas

[Sultan Yusuf]

Originally Posted by Daoud Cant really fault Clarke. The match was realistically over before he got out and the tailend slogging was akin to Astle's double century against England. Great entertainment and kept a hope alive when there wasnt any but once the thought of an Aussie comeback started spreading there really wasnt any way it would happen cause the pressure was back on them. Its all good slogging when the pressure is off, but it rarely comes off when it comes back to them

Perfect example of some of Misbah's knocks recently.

Altho to be fair to him, he is improving in that department.

[DHONI183]

Originally Posted by Daoud Cant really fault Clarke. The match was realistically over before he got out and the tailend slogging was akin to Astle's double century against England. Great entertainment and kept a hope alive when there wasnt any but once the thought of an Aussie comeback started spreading there really wasnt any way it would happen cause the pressure was back on them. Its all good slogging when the pressure is off, but it rarely comes off when it comes back to them

Totally agree . He had to go for his shots.

[Saj]

Originally Posted by Daoud Cant really fault Clarke. The match was realistically over before he got out and the tailend slogging was akin to Astle's double century against England. Great entertainment and kept a hope alive when there wasnt any but once the thought of an Aussie comeback started spreading there really wasnt any way it would happen cause the pressure was back on them. Its all good slogging when the pressure is off, but it rarely comes off when it comes back to them

The thing is Daoud, yes I agree about him having to attack and go for the runs, but the mode and type of dismissal was extremely poor in my opinion. Clarke had quite literally jumped down the track before Kumble had released the ball.

I just wonder about Clarke's temperament. Would a Steve Waugh or an Alan Border have done such a thing?

[Daoud]

Originally Posted by Saj The thing is Daoud, yes I agree about him having to attack and go for the runs, but the mode and type of dismissal was extremely poor in my opinion. Clarke had quite literally jumped down the track before Kumble had released the ball. I just wonder about Clarke's temperament. Would a Steve Waugh or an Alan Border have done such a thing?

No but with those players they have the benefit of being judged on the basis of their whole career. Of all the Aussie players, Clarke is easily the quickest on his feet and has the most assured footwork against spin so he must have felt he'd get to the pitch of the ball (which he clearly didnt). But think back to Damien Martyn's dismissal in the Sydney test vs South Africa back in 1993/94 which ended his test career for 5 or 6 years. Who would have thought that same player was capable of the incredibly mature and important innings he would play a decade later in the subcontinent

[Neighbourhood policewala]

Originally Posted by Saj The thing is Daoud, yes I agree about him having to attack and go for the runs, but the mode and type of dismissal was extremely poor in my opinion. Clarke had quite literally jumped down the track before Kumble had released the ball. I just wonder about Clarke's temperament. Would a Steve Waugh or an Alan Border have done such a thing?

Clarke is a classy batsman and the way he was driving was an example of the perfect shots..In response to your question above Saj, I think Clarke is a different type of batsman whose natural game is based on attacking intent, Border and Waugh were more grafters in mymind who would grind out runs

[jackal786]

But you gotta say he was beaten in flight.. I think he thought he was in position only to realize he was far away from the ball. That is clarke's style of batting. He kinda lunges towards the ball when he plays spinners. I think he got out in similar fashion at Sydney or Melbourne.

[jackal786]

But.. this is a good point that Kaneria should take note of when he plays against ozzies. Kumble has fooled him twice like that. A real teaser both times.

[Random Aussie]

That's the way Clarke plays - uses his feet. He batted well, Kumble just beat him.

The crucial wicket was Gilly though, when he was out we had basically no chance.

[Arif_India]

Originally Posted by Random Aussie That's the way Clarke plays - uses his feet. He batted well, Kumble just beat him. The crucial wicket was Gilly though, when he was out we had basically no chance.

Yep. I agree.. he is a good player of spin, uses his feet a lot. This time Kumble was expecting it and he bowled it short.

[iafzal]

Originally Posted by Saj We've all seen those horror dismissals where a batsman plays a horrendous stroke at a crucial juncture of the game and gets himself out. Today Michael Clarke jumped down the wicket so far, that his dismissal could almsot have been declared a runout, rather than a stumping. It gave Dhoni so much time that he could have done a few steps of the bhangra and then taken the bails off. What was Clarke thinking at a time when he was their last realistic hope?

That in cricket terms is called Afridian slip where a batsman plays without using an iota of his brain.

[flawed_genius]

Over rated player for me. Not at all captain material.

[Sparhawk]

Until that shot he was playing superbly. I was impressed with his footwork under pressure, usually batsmen go into a shell but he was a perfect example of controlled attacking. Gilchrist and lee's back to back dismissals must have thrown him off his rythm. I think he's gonna sort that out with experience, other than that he is a top class batsman in the making.

[Easa]

Clarke is a weird case. He looks so good at times while batting and strings up a few good scores but then goes quiet for 5/6 games. If he brings consistency into his game, he has the makings of a really good batsman; he has all the strokes, he's a quick runner between the wickets, and he has the temperament to succeed. Just needs to smooth out a few rough edges and then its party time.

[WasimG]

Originally Posted by mooz did we really need a new thread over ONE dismissal?

Are you ever happy with anything? But I agree with you this time.