2nd 0di Points

[Dr_Bassim]

I am gonna start creating a point system now.. .so that all those people who are thinking our team is really good and world-beater and we just are unlucky, see the actual efficiency of the team after every match

Today
Butt 0
No catch, bowled nothing, got out on nothing
Kamran 1
kept wickets, got run out stupidly on 16
Younus 0
nothing
Umar Akmal 0
did nothing
Shoaib Malik 1
took two catches which would have been dropped by every other player sans Afridi
Shahid Afridi 5
i thought he bowled beautifully and put brakes on Australia from reaching 300
Yousaf 6
Took two catches, scored a 50, and got most of the decisions related to captaincy correct except that horror of bowling first
Aamir 5
Took 3 wickets, didn't trouble with new ball or would get more points, bowled nicely at end
Gul 0.5
Took a catch and bowled horribly
Rana 1
Made some runs but bowled badly on a pitch suiting fast bowlers
Ajmal 5
He did his job. Bowled adequately


Now tell me if our top 5 batsmen do nothing in the game... And you call this team World-BEATERS...
Prepare for some more embarrasment

[Azrim_91]

dammm ur ratings are so horrible. you need to rethink. Malik 1??

i'd give him at least 4 or 5 for taking 2 amazing catches and bowling really well too!!

rethink mate... plus this post has been started somewhere else too.

[rhussain33]

Dr Bassim i think you need to check my thread

Todays Order of Performance for Pakistan....

I kinda given up on it these past matches...

heres a sample post.

http://www.pakpassion.net/ppforum/sh...1&postcount=28

[Dr_Bassim]

Originally Posted by Azrim_91 dammm ur ratings are so horrible. you need to rethink. Malik 1?? i'd give him at least 4 or 5 for taking 2 amazing catches and bowling really well too!! rethink mate... plus this post has been started somewhere else too.

Wait, last i knew.. Malik was in his team for his batting ??

[Dr_Bassim]

Originally Posted by rhussain33 Dr Bassim i think you need to check my thread Todays Order of Performance for Pakistan.... I kinda given up on it these past matches... heres a sample post. http://www.pakpassion.net/ppforum/sh...1&postcount=28

Lol why did you give up .. any specific reasons ?

[Azrim_91]

Originally Posted by Dr_Bassim Wait, last i knew.. Malik was in his team for his batting ??

your point system is not based on how they performed to what they are "asked to do"

everyone needs to field... and shoaib malik is an allrounder.... enough said.

he performed well.. its a shame he got out... it was a good catch by ponting. yes he shoulve kept it down.. but him and moyo were doing the right thing in getting their eye in...

[Afridi_Fan]

Shouldn't get one more point for his catch of Pup?

Just a thought.

[Dr_Bassim]

Originally Posted by Afridi_Fan Shouldn't get one more point for his catch of Pup? Just a thought.

You are right forgot that..

Afridi 6
Malik 4 Happy Azrim .. two for his catches.... and one for his four over spell

[sali]

Bottom line, we can't chase anything. Playing under light when the ball swings was never going to work for our batsman. It may have helped out spin bowlers but we will always get out under 200 in these conditions.

[farhan1]

Originally Posted by Dr_Bassim You are right forgot that.. Afridi 6 Malik 4 Happy Azrim .. two for his catches.... and one for his four over spell

Saeed Ajmal should have more points because he done the job with the bowl.

[SlowerBall]

The ratings are a bit harsh to say the least.

[Dr_Bassim]

Lol if you can add anymore points to the top 5 batsmen .. by telling a reason i will be happy
Shoaib Malik got 4 .. after the edit.. feel free to think where you can add in the top 5 batsmen

[WithLoveFromCanada]

dont rana deserve one more point for his 27 runs - being the second highest run scorer for the Pakistan team?

[Black Zero]

YK should be given less numbers. You have given him too much.

[Black Zero]

Kamran runout was MoYo mistake (Kami isn't the first victim of MoYo's) as commentrator rightly said "Kami had to return from half-way, had they run it would have been a simple single"

So Kami shud get 3 for keeping (had to keep close for 24 overs) and 2 for his innings
Total 5.

2 scores should be deducted from MoYo for getting him run out.

[Black Zero]

Butt got the correct numbers from you.
But I think Umer deserved 1 number for his face expressions.

[Black Zero]

Now about Shoaib Malik.

I know fan react when their favorite player doesn't perform to their expectations.

I'll give him 2 each for both catches, even afridi would have dropped one of those. But I'd deduct a point for missing run out, so net 3 for fielding alone.

If Ajmal can get 5 for his off spin, then SM deserves 2 for his 4 overs (SR was is same range). Net 2 for bowling.

I'll give 1/2 point for each run, so Net 1 point for batting.

Fair and Honest Grand Net : 3+2+1 = 6

[Farhan!]

Originally Posted by Dr_Bassim Now tell me if our top 5 batsmen do nothing in the game... And you call this team World-BEATERS... Prepare for some more embarrasment

Who does?

I don't think anyone on PakPassion does.

[insaaniyat]

Originally Posted by Dr_Bassim I am gonna start creating a point system now.. .so that all those people who are thinking our team is really good and world-beater and we just are unlucky, see the actual efficiency of the team after every match Today Butt 0 No catch, bowled nothing, got out on nothing Kamran 1 kept wickets, got run out stupidly on 16 Younus -6 nothing Umar Akmal 0 did nothing Shoaib Malik 1 took two catches which would have been dropped by every other player sans Afridi Shahid Afridi 5 i thought he bowled beautifully and put brakes on Australia from reaching 300 Yousaf 6 Took two catches, scored a 50, and got most of the decisions related to captaincy correct except that horror of bowling first Aamir 5 Took 3 wickets, didn't trouble with new ball or would get more points, bowled nicely at end Gul 0.5 Took a catch and bowled horribly Rana 1 Made some runs but bowled badly on a pitch suiting fast bowlers Ajmal 5 He did his job. Bowled adequately Now tell me if our top 5 batsmen do nothing in the game... And you call this team World-BEATERS... Prepare for some more embarrasment

everything is fine. I fixed the red for you

[Saqs]

Younis showed good energy on the field - it was a welcome change to see that.

His dismissal was a direct result of the extremely poor start our two openers gave us - which was absolutely atrocious ODI batting. Still can't believe Imran Nazir isn't in the side.

[Gollum]

I would take a couple of points away from MoYo and give it to Rana. MoYo not only got the toss decision wrong, but he also got the bowling order wrong. It should have been Rana bowling the new ball spell with Aamir and not Gul. I believe Rana's figures may have turned out better if he was given the new ball and us having to chase 30 fewer runs perhaps (not that it would have mattered probably).

[mamoo gogo]

doctor saab, these are by far the worst ratings i've come across...